Program on Church, State & Society has announced the winners of its annual writing competition

Author: Nicole Kilbourne

Notre Dame Law School’s Program on Church, State & Society has announced the winners of its annual writing competition. The goal of the competition is to encourage scholarship related to the intersection of church, state, and society, and in particular how the law structures and governs that intersection.

Dennis Wieboldt

First place went to Dennis Wieboldt, a University of Notre Dame J.D. and Ph.D. student in history, for his paper, “The ‘Crusading Fanatics’ of American Law: American Jesuits and the Origins of the Neo-Scholastic Legal Revival, 1870-1960." He received a cash prize of $3,000.

Wieboldt's article offers a revisionist account of the development of modern American legal philosophy. In particular, it reveals how the world's largest Catholic religious order, the Society of Jesus, transmitted important features of European Catholic intellectual culture into the United States' emerging network of Catholic law schools during the first few decades of the twentieth century. In doing so, Wieboldt's article explains why Jesuit legal scholars became the most influential critics of the positivist turn in American legal philosophy, as perhaps best illustrated by the fact that former U.S. Attorney General Francis Biddle devoted one of his three inaugural Oliver Wendell Holmes Devise lectures in 1960 to criticizing little-known Jesuits who had critiqued Biddle's late judicial mentor.

Jeremy Ross

Second place was awarded to Jeremy Ross, a rising third-year student at the University of Virginia. He received a cash prize of $2,000 for his paper, “The Implications of Fulton’s Individualized Exemption Doctrine for Free Exercise, Affirmation Requirements, and Foster Care.”

Ross argues that Fulton v. City of Philadelphia has cast doubt on the ability of foster care agencies to impose lifestyle requirements that contradict religious teachings so that states will struggle to prohibit fostering by religious parents who adhere to traditional views of sexuality and gender.

“Many observers have considered Fulton to be a narrow decision, and even an act of evasion by the Supreme Court intended to forestall major changes in the law surrounding religious liberty,” said Ross. “I show in my paper that this view of Fulton is incorrect, and that its holding on individualized exemptions will be massively influential in any area of policy where state actors interact with private citizens on a case-by-case basis, such as foster care. Likewise, while Fulton has been commonly viewed as a conservative decision, its holding could also theoretically protect religious liberals.”

Kristen Clarke

Kristen Clarke, a rising third-year student at William S. Boyd School of Law, University of Nevada-Las Vegas won third place prize with her paper, “"Groff v. DeJoy: A More Than De Minimis Tool Toward a Pluralistic Society." She received a cash prize of $1,000.

In her paper, Clarke analyzes a 2023 Supreme Court decision on religious accommodations in employment under Title VII. Initially, the decision seemed poised to have minimal impact: it was short, unanimous, and framed as a clarification of an earlier standard. However, the "clarified" standard significantly differs from the previous one, promising greater participation for religious adherents in American society without the "cruel choice" between employment and faith. Although the case involved a Christian seeking accommodations for Sunday Sabbath observance, Clarke focuses on its impact on religious minorities needing greater accommodations in a predominantly Christian society.

Clarke said she chose her topic of interest because she is a law student, a mother of six, and a woman of faith. “As a person whose important life decisions have each been impacted by my faith, I believe that religious freedom is an essential component of human dignity, and that a person's faith is a fundamental part of their identity. I believe the concept of religious freedom has greater strength when it is seen as universal, and its universality is best recognized when considered from multiple angles and viewpoints. This is why I study religious freedom from the perspective of religious minorities,” said Clarke.

Joshua Lollar

Honorable mention went to Joshua Lollar for his paper, “Prayer for Relief: Church, Court, and Immediate Appeal in Ministerial Exception Cases.” He received a cash prize of $500. The rising third-year student at University of Kansas School of Law argues that preliminary orders in employment discrimination suits against religious employers should be immediately appealable under the collateral order doctrine. He contends that such cases implicating church autonomy are the kinds of cases that the collateral order doctrine is intended to address. Lollar argues more generally that the religion clauses of the First Amendment, and the place of religion in American society, demand immediate appealability.

Lollar said, “My essay promotes a vision of the common good in which the involvement of religious institutions in society, including the courts, is not one of antagonism or aloofness but rather of participation, support, and instruction.”

The Program on Church, State & Society’s annual writing competition is open to law students in good standing, enrolled in a traditional law degree, a master’s degree, or a doctoral degree program at an ABA-accredited law school within the United States. The competition is also open to recent graduates not yet practicing law, including those completing clerkships or engaged in similar pursuits. Submissions are judged anonymously.

Originally published by Nicole Kilbourne at law.nd.edu on July 24, 2024.